RSS Feeds RSS | Views on ITInews | contact | terms of use | privacy 

Editorial Categories:


Forthcoming Events:

No Upcoming Events

Save by getting insurance quotes

Proudly South AfricanInforming Consumers and Financial Advisors since 1988 | Click Here to Advertise
Car, household, life and business insurance quotes

News Article : Where will growth come from?
Category: Economy & Global : Local Economy
Author:Jac Laubscher
Email:[email protected]
Posted:15 Oct 2015

 Email this article Comment on this Article  Print this article

The absence of an inherently independent growth dynamic in the economy

It is common knowledge by now that South Africa is stuck in a low-growth rut with growth forecasts continuing to be downgraded (the IMF being the latest to do so) and the prospect of a return to 3%+ growth being pushed out.

This state of affairs is partly ascribed to a weak global growth outlook, and partly to domestic constraints.

However, before we get too despondent about this it is worth noting that South Africa is nevertheless doing better than some other commodity-exporting countries, e.g. Brazil and Russia, which find themselves in recession.

In fact, it is quite remarkable that South Africa’s growth rate remains positive, even if it is at a lowly 1,5%, in spite of all the obstacles in its way - once again demonstrating the well-known resilience of the economy (or the private sector, to be more specific).

The extreme irony is perhaps that because South Africa did not fully participate in the commodity super cycle in the early 2000s due to policy failures, and later on unstable labour conditions, it now feels the negative impact of the commodity downturn to a lesser extent.

Although there was a spurt in investment in the mining sector in 2006-2008, it was not accompanied by any meaningful expansion in production capacity and the contribution of the primary sector to the economy continued to decline.

In the decade to 2010 the primary sector made almost no contribution to growth in gross value added, expanding cumulatively by only 4%, compared with an increase of 41% for the economy as a whole.

In fact, in the decade to 2010 gross value added by the mining sector in particular declined in five out of the 10 years to record a cumulative decline of 0,2% for the period.

In nominal terms the sector of course did benefit from higher commodity prices.

Furthermore, the prudent fiscal policy followed by South Africa at the time by not squandering the tax overrun created the necessary room for the expansionary policy adopted after the economy moved into recession in 2009, even though the way in which this room was used was suboptimal (by and large taking the form of an explosion in the government wage bill) with little long-term benefit to the economy.

The danger is that we could easily become complacent about our lack of growth, ascribing it to poor international economic conditions over which we have no control, or the electricity constraint that in time will be resolved, enabling us to grow as usual.

In other words, we should just sit back and bear with it until the problem resolves itself.

However, such an attitude will not do as it will make us lose sight of fundamental flaws in our approach to growth.

The strong correlation between the South African business cycle and the global cycle is a long-standing feature of our economy that demonstrates the absence of an inherently independent growth dynamic in the economy.

It is something that needs to be consciously addressed as it has been a major cause of our stop-start growth history.

The weak prospects for the global economy, e.g. as set out in the IMF’s recent World Economic Outlook, lend further urgency to this objective.

Of course South Africa cannot and should not try to isolate itself from the global economy. That would deprive it of an obvious channel to lift its growth rate.

However, South Africa is small enough in a global context to be able to follow a niche strategy that could at least partly hedge the economy against negative developments at a global level.

That South Africa’s economic well-being continues to be dependent on the commodity cycle is an indictment of its inability to modernise and diversify its economy.

It is problematic that the bulk of export earnings still comes from natural resources, in spite of the contribution of the primary sector to GDP having declined from 27% in 1970 to 10% currently and continuing to do so.

A shift in export focus is inter alia required if South Africa is to continue benefiting from its relationship with China, even if the credibility of the latter’s official growth statistics is questionable.

The long-anticipated rebalancing of the Chinese economy from unsustainably high investment to greater reliance on consumption as driver of growth implies a similar rebalancing in Chinese imports from commodities to consumer goods and services.

The challenge for South Africa is to adjust to the Chinese rebalancing by changing its export mix accordingly.

But there are numerous soft issues holding back growth, culminating in sustained high growth clearly not being a policy priority for the South African government.

Its focus is on redistributing the fruits of what growth is achieved rather than maximising it, and transforming the economic landscape according to political priorities without regard to the implications thereof for growth.

For example, since Joseph Schumpeter put the entrepreneur at the centre of economic development it has been widely accepted that governments should create a favourable environment for entrepreneurship and not resist the process of “creative destruction” that is inextricably part of a dynamic economy.

But then South Africa’s black economic empowerment policy does exactly the opposite through its influence on incentive structures.

Black business people are encouraged to lay claim to part ownership of an existing business (the larger and more established the better) rather than take the risk of starting their own ventures, while potential white entrepreneurs have to reckon with the requirement to share their success with black partners in spite of bearing the full start-up risk (no similar requirement applies to potential black entrepreneurs).

The lack of urgency in encouraging economic growth is further illustrated by the contrast in the energy and the drive put into social and redistributive policy initiatives (e.g. national health insurance and a national minimum
wage) compared with the absence of forceful action in addressing the structural constraints that for many years have been acknowledged to be holding back the economy.

These include inter alia the education crisis, labour market instability and inflexibility (in the sense of wages often not reflecting productivity and labour force mobility being limited), and poor service and infrastructure delivery.

To achieve the required growth rate to meet the challenges of unemployment and poverty, South Africa will have to find a better balance between growth on the one hand and transformation and redistribution on the other hand.

It will also have to reconsider the way in which it strives to achieve its transformation objectives to create an environment in which entrepreneurship and initiative are amply rewarded.

There are no comments at this stage. Be the first to comment!
Please Login To Comment On an Article - Click here To Login

ITInews invites comments at the foot of each of its articles in which readers can respond freely - anonymously if they wish - to various topical issues and industry debates. However, comments submitted by readers that are defamatory or deemed, by the editors, to be racist or obscene will be deleted from the database. Furthermore, ITInews's editor would like to caution potential posters on its websites that while it welcomes robust debate, it will not hesitate to make the IP addresses of the authors of such defamatory statements available to the authorities, in the event of a court order compelling them to do so.

Get car, home, life and business insurance quotes in 3 easy steps

Join us today

Insurance Quotes

Car Insurance Quotes
Household Insurance Quotes
Business Insurance Quotes
Funeral Insurance Quotes
Life Insurance Quotes

Read the InsuranceQuotes Blog

Economy & Global - Local Economy
Disaster Insurance
Global Economy
Local Economy

More in Economy & Global : Local Economy
Can South Africa avoid junk status? (Part 2)
The risk of a downgrade in the near future is relatively high
Can South Africa avoid junk status? (Part 1)
The South African government does not have a growth policy
South Africa falls short of national savings ‘pass rate’: first Savings Index launched
Investec GIBS Savings Index
Aligning monetary and fiscal policy
Is a tightening of monetary policy in conjunction with an unavoidably tight fiscal policy the best o
The effect of indigenisation, such as BEE, on financial development
Indigenisation as an economic intervention is frustrated by high levels of corruption
The insolvency U-turn
Euler Hermes Economic Outlook 2015-16
Where will growth come from? Part 2
A possible growth strategy in the current global environment
The (not-so-) hidden message of the Medium Term Budget
South Africa needs to reconstruct social consensus behind a path of accelerated economic growth
Contracting GDP detrimental to SME development
2015 was expected to be a better year ...
The SARB and the carry trade
Trying to support the exchange rate of the rand by hiking interest rates is an exercise in futility
Why small business does not create jobs
In South Africa we are self-employed out of necessity
The state of South Africa’s political economy
A pragmatic rather than an ideological approach
The Fall in Private Investment
South Africa’s potential growth rate has suffered long-term damage
The Management of Government Debt
South Africa runs the risk of its credit rating being downgraded
A few thoughts on the slide in oil prices
The implications of lower oil prices for South Africa are numerous and mostly advantageous
SA consumers cut back on socialising as tough economic conditions
But gifting still a significant portion of budget
Visa African Integration Index shows improvement
But long way off the global median
South African digital economy the most developed in Africa – MasterCard Index
South Africa, Egypt, Kenya and Nigeria are quickly moving towards digital evolution
The threat of secular stagnation
It is generally accepted that structural reforms are the only answer
A medium-term budget: an effort to draw the line
Weak economic performance has enforced material consolidation of fiscal policy

Available Recruitment:
No Vacancies Listed...

ITM Website Design Cape Town
Copyright © 2005 - 2015 ITInews Online Publications (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved Insurance Times & Investments Online and ITInews. ..::ISSN 1995-1256::.. No part of the materials including graphics or logos, available in this Web site may be copied, photocopied, reproduced, translated or reduced to any electronic medium or machine-readable form, in whole or in part, without specific permission from ITInews Online Publications (Pty) Ltd. Distribution for commercial purposes is prohibited.